Ederik Schneider Online

Freedom or Totalitarianism

Freedom or Totalitarianism
Liberty or Death

Monday, April 30, 2012

Author David Brin on "Dogmatic Libertarians, Transparency, and Uplifting": What Libertarianism Should be About



Author David Brin is dead right about how he critiques the current Libertarian Movement. That I've described as not pro Limited Government, which is what Liberals and Conservatives believe in. The way you hear Libertarians talk today, like Peter Schiff and Judge Andrew Napalitano talk. They don't even now sound pro Small Government but anti Government. They seem to take the approach that Government is incompetent period and doesn't do anything right. Which is why I'm a Liberal and not a Libertarian, I believe when you limit Government. Especially the Federal Government to doing only what it should and what it has the Constitutional Authority to do. You produce Good Government, thats not only Cost Effective but does a good job. The way you hear Libertarians talking today, you would think Good Government is an Oxymoron. And thats why I'm not a Libertarian, because Libertarians today sound anarchist. Or perhaps just a step away from being anarchists.

Liberals want to limit government to what it only should be doing, again based on its Constitutional Authority. And what its effective at and can do in a Cost Effective way. And have an Economic System, where everyone has Quality of Opportunity. To be successful in life, which is what Equality of Opportunity is about. And what the people do with these Opportunities, is up to them and that they should be rewarded for what they produce for society. Not be rewarded for what they are lacking in order to be Self Sufficient in life. Whereas Progressives have more of a Collectivist Communitarian view of Government and the economy. That we are one nation, one family, one community and in this environment. No one should have a lot more then anyone, even if they've worked and earned it. That we need to heavily tax this Excess Wealth, to take care of the people who can't take care of themselves.

Libertarians today seem to take the view that Government has created all of the problems. And has none of the solutions to fix these problems. And that it shouldn't even be involved in areas like Law Enforcement and Corrections. Because its so incompetent and that these things should be privatized. I'm waiting to hear a Libertarian come out in favor of privatizing the military, maybe thats next. And why even though they are growing, are yet to be seen as a Mainstream Movement. But with Gary Johnson getting the Libertarian Nomination for President. He could bring Liberals into the LP and maybe the Movement will change.